When looking for synonyms for the phrase "more arty-crafty," several options come to mind. Firstly, the term "artsy" is often used to refer to someone or something that is creative or artistic. Similarly, the phrase "crafty" can be replaced with "handmade" or "DIY" to convey a similar sense of creativity. Additionally, the word "artisanal" can be used to describe handmade or handcrafted items. Other synonyms include "creative," "innovative," "imaginative," and "resourceful." Ultimately, the perfect synonym will depend on the context and the specific qualities that the speaker is looking to convey.